I recently opened my “CODEX Beta Readers 2017” Scrivener document and took a look at some of their feedback in response to the twenty questions I submitted when they agreed to read the novel. Some of that feedback is worth quoting here, I think.
Let me start by saying that one beta reader recently told me that she’s re-read her beta copy of the novel nine times. NINE TIMES. I had to take a moment to let that comment sink in — and when it did, I jumped up out of my chair and did a little victory dance around the home studio. To touch a reader that deeply is what writing is all about (for me, at any rate).
Another beta reader (let’s call her Beta #1), in her feedback to the Twenty Questions, noted:
“The book was gripping, I had to put it down for periods of time to absorb what I had read, but I always came back because I had to know what happens next.”
In response to the question “Was the climax of the book satisfying?”, Beta #1 replied:
“NO the climax of the book was not satisfying, it was appalling, the idea that [SPOILER REDACTED] is terrifying. Having said that, you made sure that the climax was impactful in the extreme! I was appalled, and scared and grieving, I very rarely feel so much response to a book. Thank you Laurie, I look forward to the next instalment with fear and delight.”
The question “Would you recommend this book to readers?” prompted the response:
“Yes I would shove this book into peoples hands and demand that they read it! It is compelling in it’s own right and I can see parallels in today’s world that we can learn from.”
Beta #2 felt much the same way:
“Hell yes! It’s an engaging book that is well written with a theme that is unique and well plotted. There’s angst and love and curiosity rolled into one. Overall, a delightful read :)”
Beta #2’s response to the question of whether the book gripped them and made them want to keep reading:
“Hell yes! Everything was plausible (Plus I’m a sucker for Dinosaurs). The tension between characters was well played out plus the use of dialog was interesting. Especially in the beginning, when you were describing how the language of the Greaters sounded to Raoul.”
Beta #3 noted:
“As a reader of classic literature, non-fiction and narrative fiction, this book was outside of my typical genre. I found the beginning very intriguing, and was quite surprised when the character was drawn into the body of a dinosaur. It took me a bit to get settled into the story, but once I was drawn in by the character development, rich dialogue and colourful descriptions, I was very intrigued by the story.”
A fitting note to end on, I think, is the short review submitted by the beta reader who has read the MS nine times so far:
“I just finished reading an incredible book. I was honored to be a beta reader for it. When it is published. I will be sure to make a point of letting all of you know about it. It’s singularly one of the best books I have ever read, and I’ve read ALL the great sci-fi/fantasy fiction masters and mistresses. Just. Fucking. Wow.”
And it’s that kind of feedback, folks, that makes eighteen months of intensely hard worth TOTALLY worthwhile.
You can find “The Codex of Desire” on Amazon (ebook and paperback) and on Smashwords (many different electronic formats). Both sites have the preview function enabled, so you can look inside before you buy. 🙂



